TOLSTOY FOUNDATION REHABILITATION AND NRSG CENTER

100 LAKE ROAD, VALLEY COTTAGE, NY 10989

Paul Richards, RN, MSHIReviewed by Paul Richards, RN, MSHI|Data updated April 2026

TOLSTOY FOUNDATION REHABILITATION AND NRSG CENTER is a skilled nursing facility located at 100 LAKE ROAD, VALLEY COTTAGE, NY 10989. The facility accepts both Medicare and Medicaid and holds a CMS rating of 1 star overall, with a 1-star health inspection rating, 1-star staffing rating, and 2-star quality measures rating. Ratings are sourced from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and updated monthly.

Overall

1

Health

1

Staffing

1

Quality

2

Source: CMS.gov — Updated April 2026

AI Insights

Sentiment: 20/100

Families love

+Some staff are hardworking and dedicated
+Entertainment and housekeeping services available

Worth knowing

-Poor response to call buttons
-Inadequate personal hygiene care
-Financial management issues
-Minimal staff supervision of residents

Based on 24 public reviews — AI-generated by CareNav

Family Reviews

3.2

24 reviews on Google

Kristin D'Urso
a month ago

My mother was briefly here in 2024 - I'm writing this review now because I just found some notes I had written about the awful conditions and treatment there. It was so bad that I had her transferred...

Michael Mann
3 months ago

My company provides medical equipment for Tolstoy. They have overdue bills and seem to be having financial hardships. A employee named Maribel who we were told is in charge on invoices has been avoidi...

Susan Kuhlmann
a year ago

My Mom has been in their care going on two years, the care team are hard working, dedicated staff and take good care of her. The entertainment, housekeeping, laundry and food services staff are also k...

lisa Treglia
a year ago

Doesn’t even deserve one star but I needed to write a review. I am beyond appalled and disgusted. My Aunt got brought here by accident as the hospital was supposed to send her to a good place. Well le...

Sylvia Romero
2 years ago

The staff at Tolstoy is one of the most unique, extraordinary and caring group of people I've ever come across in a Nursing Home Rehab. My mom was cared for with dignity and compassion which helped he...

Reviews from Google — Updated April 2026

More nursing homes in VALLEY COTTAGE

View all facilities in VALLEY COTTAGE
Loading map...

Care types

Skilled Nursing

Accepts

Medicare
Medicaid